Having several pensions can make retirement planning feel unnecessarily complicated.
You may have different providers, separate statements and several online accounts to manage. Even knowing how much you have saved overall can take time.
Combining your pensions into one plan could make them easier to monitor and give you a clearer picture of your retirement savings. However, simplicity alone does not mean a transfer will leave you better off.
Pension transfers usually cannot be reversed. Before moving any money, there are five important areas to check.
1. Could You Lose Valuable Guarantees?
Some pensions include benefits that may not be available once the money has been transferred.
These could include:
Guaranteed annuity rates
Protected pension access ages
Enhanced tax-free cash
With-profits bonuses
Guaranteed investment returns
Valuable benefits for beneficiaries
A guaranteed annuity rate, for example, may allow you to convert your pension into a higher guaranteed income than you could obtain elsewhere. Other schemes may allow you to access your pension earlier than the standard minimum pension age.
Defined benefit pensions require particular care. These schemes normally promise a guaranteed income based on factors such as your salary and length of service. Transferring into a defined contribution pension would usually mean giving up that guaranteed income and accepting investment risk instead.
Before consolidating, ask each provider for a full explanation of the guarantees and safeguarded benefits attached to the pension. Once they are lost, they will not normally be restored.
2. How Do the Charges Really Compare?
Reducing charges can be a reason to combine pensions, particularly where older plans have higher fees.
However, comparing pension costs is not always as simple as looking at one annual percentage.
Depending on the plan, you may pay:
Annual management charges
Investment fund charges
Platform or administration fees
Transaction costs
Withdrawal charges
Fees for changing investments
Advice or ongoing service charges
A new pension could have a lower headline fee but charge separately for features included within your existing plan. Equally, transferring from several higher-cost pensions into a more competitive arrangement may reduce the overall amount being deducted.
The difference may appear small each year, but charges can affect how much remains invested over the long term.
The important question is not simply which pension is cheapest. It is whether the services, investment choices and retirement options provided represent good value for your needs.
3. Will the Investment Options Suit Your Plans?
Pensions can offer very different investment choices.
Some provide a small selection of ready-made funds. Others offer a wider range of investments with different objectives, risk levels and charges.
More choice is not automatically better. What matters is whether the available investments support your retirement plans and how involved you want to be in managing them.
Consider:
How your pensions are currently invested
Whether the level of risk is appropriate
How long you have until retirement
How you intend to access the money
Whether the new plan offers suitable funds
What charges apply to those investments
If you plan to use pension drawdown, some of your money may remain invested throughout retirement. The investment strategy needed for this may be different from one designed for someone planning to withdraw their pension or purchase an annuity immediately.
Transferring without reviewing the underlying investments could result in a consolidated pension that is easier to see but no better aligned with your goals.
4. Are There Exit Penalties or Transfer Restrictions?
Some providers apply charges when a pension is transferred.
There may also be bonuses that only become available if you remain with the scheme until a particular date. Transferring shortly before that point could mean giving up more than you gain through lower charges elsewhere.
Before making a decision, ask your existing providers:
Whether an exit or transfer fee applies
What the current transfer value is
Whether any bonuses would be lost
How long the transfer value remains valid
Whether there are restrictions on transferring
How long the process is expected to take
You should also confirm that the receiving scheme accepts transfers and understand any charges for setting up or investing the transferred money.
If you are still paying into a workplace pension, check what would happen to your employer’s contributions. Many employers will only contribute to their chosen workplace scheme, so moving the pension or redirecting future payments could mean losing valuable contributions.
You do not have to combine every pension. In some cases, moving selected pots while leaving others where they are may be more appropriate.
5. Does the New Pension Offer the Flexibility You Need?
No two retirement journeys are identical because no two lives are identical.
If your career has included unexpected detours, career breaks or significant life changes, you’re far from alone.
Taking time to understand where your pension stands today won’t change the path you’ve already travelled. It can, however, give you greater confidence about the road ahead.
If you’d like to gain a clearer picture of your retirement plans, speaking with a pension expert can help you understand your options and make informed decisions based on your individual circumstances.
Look Beyond Convenience
Combining pensions can make retirement planning feel more manageable. It may also provide access to different investments, lower charges or more flexible income options.
However, the decision should be based on what you gain and what you could lose.
A financial adviser can review your existing schemes, identify valuable benefits or penalties and assess whether consolidation supports your wider retirement plans.
The right outcome may be to combine all your pensions, transfer only selected pots or leave them exactly where they are. What matters is making that decision with a complete understanding of your options.
Thinking about combining your pensions? Speak to My Pension Expert before transferring your retirement savings.
Pension advice is tailored to your individual circumstances and can help you understand the options available before making decisions about your retirement.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute personal financial advice. Pension planning should always be considered in light of your individual circumstances and retirement objectives. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and may change in the future. The value of investments can fall as well as rise and you may receive back less than you invest.